Embracing Chaos: The Art of Good Design
What Is Good Design?
Today’s Lens: Jane Jacobs
“Under the seeming disorder of the old city … is a marvelous order … an intricate ballet in which the individual dancers and ensembles all have distinctive parts which miraculously reinforce each other and compose an orderly whole.” — Jane Jacobs, The Death and Life of Great American Cities. (janeswalkottawa.ca)
Jacobs wasn’t talking about pixels, but her stance travels well: good design doesn’t impose brittle tidiness; it cultivates organized complexity. It sets the stage for many small, semi‑independent moves to reinforce one another—messy up close, coherent in the round. The opposite is a “pretended order” that suppresses the real one users create. (artsjournal.com)
Try this
- Design for ensembles, not solos: prefer multiple simple components that interlock over one “grand” feature. Think overlaps and handoffs.
- Keep faces to the street: expose state, affordances, and activity so neighboring parts (and people) can coordinate naturally.
- Short blocks, many doors: break long flows into legible steps with multiple entry points; make switching paths cheap.
- Measure the ballet: instrument interactions between parts (teams, services, screens) and optimize for the health of the whole, not isolated KPIs.
Further reading:
- The “sidewalk ballet” passage from Chapter 2 of Death and Life. (janeswalkottawa.ca)
- On the dangers of “pretended order.” (artsjournal.com)
Good design doesn’t choreograph every step; it composes conditions where many steps become a dance.