Designing with Taft: A Quirky Experiment!
The Daily Interesting — Art & Design Edition
April 03, 2026
The idea
Does your page design improve when you replace every image with William Howard Taft?[1][2]
— Maciej Cegłowski (BarnsworthBurning extract)[1]
Who said it (and the context)
Maciej Cegłowski, a Polish-American programmer, essayist, and founder of the minimalist bookmarking site Pinboard.in, coined the "Taft Test" in his 2015 talk The Website Obesity Crisis. Frustrated by text sites ballooning to megabytes via pointless images and scripts, he proposed this absurd swap—using photos of the rotund 27th U.S. President—as a litmus test for visual fluff.[2][1]
A small expansion
The test reveals if images enhance structure and meaning or just decorate. If swapping in Taft improves clarity or rhythm, your visuals were non-essential bloat—revealing reliance on eye-candy over smart layout, type, and hierarchy.[1][2]
Another lens on the idea
Edward Tufte, pioneer of data visualization, formalized this intuition with chartjunk—gratuitous "interior decoration" like decorative 3D or vibes that dilute info—and the data-ink ratio: maximize ink for data, erase the rest. Taft humorously operationalizes Tufte: if Taft suffices, your "data" (content) was carrying the design alone.[3][4]
Why this matters across art and design
Visual identity
Logos and marks: Test icons against Taft—does the symbol amplify wordmark or distract? Prioritize legible forms over trendy graphics.[1]Product & UX
Interfaces bloated with stock photos or loaders? Taft-swap exposes if layout breathes without them, boosting speed and focus.[2]Architecture
Renderings and diagrams: Replace hero images with Taft; strong plans stand via lines and space, not CGI glamour.[1]Studio art
Compositions: Taft-in vulnerable spots tests if images serve narrative or filler—echoes minimalism's purge of excess.[1]
Two quick drills
Taft Swap Sprint (10 minutes)
Grab a site, app mockup, or sketch. Download Taft portraits. Replace all images. Does it get better? Note wins/losses; redesign the losers.[1]Taft Hierarchy Audit (15 minutes)
Build a page/poster with text only + Taft placeholders. Arrange for flow. Now add one image—must earn its spot via the test.[2]
Thread to remember
Echoes detail audits (4), tiny critics (46), judgment over metrics (12), perception drills (1), tool defaults (33)—now with bloat-busting humor. Ties web craft (42,43) to timeless anti-decoration (Tufte), refining emergent systems (52 Jacobs chaos, 10 monotile).
Sources
- Central idea/quote: Maciej Cegłowski via BarnsworthBurning (extract).[1]
- Talk origin: Website Obesity Crisis (link).[2]
- Lens: Edward Tufte Visual Display... on chartjunk/data-ink (PDF chs).[4]
Try this today: Taft-test your homepage—what survives?