# Value Radar: Fresh Picks and Citigroup Insights! Newsy: Value Investor Weekly Published: 2025-10-28T12:30:01.666Z Source: https://newsyai.com/edition/e8ceb126-3a30-4f65-b54a-2d2e3300d674 Archive: https://newsyai.com/newsy/5bbbadf7-1e6d-4c85-a79b-15b39036f33d.md --- # Value Radar: 10 Fresh Ideas, then a Full Valuation Deep‑Dive on Citigroup (C) Date: October 28, 2025 (United States) This research is for educational purposes only, not investment advice. Every key assumption is sourced so you can audit it. ## Quick scan: 10 value candidates to watch next - Citigroup (C) — trading near tangible book with rising capital returns and a simpler, 5‑business model; Q3’25 TBVPS ~$95.72, CET1 ~13.4%, and continued buybacks provide downside support. We deep‑dive below. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/citigroup-third-quarter-2025-press-release-ce7d5ad9df80f225?utm_source=openai)) - Bank of America (BAC) — tangibly richer at ~1.8–1.9x TBVPS ($28.39), but still levered to improving markets and IB cycle; strong capital return cadence. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/bank-of-america-3rd-quarter-results-ce7d5adfda81fe2d?utm_source=openai)) - JPMorgan (JPM) — best‑in‑class returns; TBVPS ~$105.7; trades at a premium multiple reflecting franchise quality. ([investing.com](https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/jpmorgan-q3-2025-slides-net-income-jumps-12-yoy-despite-market-challenges-93CH-4286846?utm_source=openai)) - Wells Fargo (WFC) — asset cap lifted; ROTCE target raised to 17–18%; TBVPS ~$44, but multiple now closer to peers. ([reuters.com](https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/wells-fargo-profit-rises-higher-interest-income-2025-10-14/?utm_source=openai)) - Shell (SHEL) — disciplined capital returns (15th straight quarter of ≥$3B buybacks) and cost cuts; yield plus buybacks support value. ([shell.gcs-web.com](https://shell.gcs-web.com/news-releases/news-release-details/shell-plc-2nd-quarter-2025-half-year-unaudited-results?utm_source=openai)) - Kraft Heinz (KHC) — mixed topline but robust FCF conversion (≥95% guide); watch margin rebuild vs. impairments. ([news.kraftheinzcompany.com](https://news.kraftheinzcompany.com/press-releases-details/2025/Kraft-Heinz-Reports-Second-Quarter-2025-Results-Maintains-Full-Year-2025-Outlook/default.aspx?utm_source=openai)) - eBay (EBAY) — high margins, ongoing buybacks and dividends; marketplace resilience with 6% revenue growth in Q2’25. ([investors.ebayinc.com](https://investors.ebayinc.com/investor-news/press-release-details/2025/eBay-Inc--Reports-Second-Quarter-2025-Results/default.aspx?utm_source=openai)) - Williams‑Sonoma (WSM) — double‑digit margin, raised 2025 revenue outlook; strong cash generation through cycles. ([ir.williams-sonomainc.com](https://ir.williams-sonomainc.com/investor-information/news-releases/news-release-details/2025/Williams-Sonoma-Inc--announces-second-quarter-2025-results/default.aspx?utm_source=openai)) - Charles Schwab (SCHW) — renewed $20B buyback authorization; levered to rate path but valuation improved. ([reuters.com](https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/charles-schwab-authorizes-20-billion-stock-buyback-declares-dividends-2025-07-24/?utm_source=openai)) - Kroger (KR) — merger overhang removed; refocus on core operations and cash returns post‑Albertsons deal collapse. ([apnews.com](https://apnews.com/article/41263bd9137d5046a642e7d26e98cdfc?utm_source=openai)) --- # Pick of the edition: Citigroup (C) ## Why it’s timely - Reseted, simpler bank at a discount: Citi trades around $100.99 today while Q3’25 tangible book value per share (TBVPS) is ~$95.72; the stock is near 1.05x TBV despite improving returns. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/citigroup-third-quarter-2025-press-release-ce7d5ad9df80f225?utm_source=openai)) - Clear progress on the plan: 2025 results show broad‑based revenue growth, expense control, and capital return acceleration (dividends + large buybacks). Management is targeting double‑digit ROTCE by 2026. ([cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/15/citigroup-c-earnings-q2-2025.html?utm_source=openai)) - Capital and balance‑sheet strength: CET1 ~13.4% leaves flexibility for ongoing buybacks and risk‑weighted asset optimization. ([sec.gov](https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/0000831001/000083100125000086/c-20250331.htm?utm_source=openai)) - Fresh catalysts: Q3’25 delivered higher EPS even with a Mexico stake sale loss; Banamex path now a staged sell‑down/IPO, simplifying the footprint. ([reuters.com](https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/citigroup-profit-climbs-record-revenue-while-mexico-sale-drags-2025-10-14/?utm_source=openai)) ## Business snapshot and roadmap - How Citi makes money now: five interconnected engines — Services (TTS and Securities Services), Markets, Banking, U.S. Personal Banking, and Wealth — after exiting 14 international consumer markets. The mix skews to fee‑rich, capital‑light Services and institutional flows. ([cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/15/citigroup-c-earnings-q2-2025.html?utm_source=openai)) - 2025 performance markers: - Q2’25: Revenue $21.7B (+8% y/y), EPS $1.96; ROTCE 8.7%; updated 2025 revenue guide around $84B; buybacks stepped up. ([gurufocus.com](https://www.gurufocus.com/news/2978430/citigroup-inc-c-q2-2025-earnings-eps-of-196-and-revenue-of-217-billion-surpass-estimates?utm_source=openai)) - Q3’25: Net income +16% y/y despite Banamex stake‑sale loss; ROTCE ~8% reported, ~9.7% ex‑Banamex loss; TBVPS up to ~$95.72; shares outstanding down to ~1.79B. ([reuters.com](https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/citigroup-profit-climbs-record-revenue-while-mexico-sale-drags-2025-10-14/?utm_source=openai)) - Capital returns: - Dividend lifted to $0.60/q (Q3 start) and a large buyback authorization (commonly cited around $20B in 2025 communications). ([investing.com](https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/citigroup-q2-2025-presentation-revenue-jumps-8-announces-20b-buyback-93CH-4135508?utm_source=openai)) ## What the market is debating - “Citi perpetually lags peers.” ROTCE has trailed JPM/BAC, but simplification and mix shift are closing the gap; management and several street views see 10–11% ROTCE in 2026. ([investopedia.com](https://www.investopedia.com/citi-earnings-q2-fy2025-11769905?utm_source=openai)) - “Book value trap.” TBVPS continues to rise (Q2→Q3), even with restructuring charges, and buybacks at or near TBV are accretive. ([gurufocus.com](https://www.gurufocus.com/news/2978430/citigroup-inc-c-q2-2025-earnings-eps-of-196-and-revenue-of-217-billion-surpass-estimates?utm_source=openai)) - “Macro will swamp returns.” Rates have eased but remain near ~4% on the 10‑year, and markets/IB cycles have improved in 2025; Citi’s diversified fee engines (Services/Markets) offset NII swings. ([ycharts.com](https://ycharts.com/indicators/10_year_treasury_rate_h15?utm_source=openai)) --- ## Ground‑up valuation: residual‑income DCF (best for banks) and comps Because banks’ free cash flow is constrained by regulatory capital, we value Citi with a residual‑income DCF: value equals today’s tangible common equity (TCE) plus the present value of future “excess returns” (ROTCE minus cost of equity) earned on that TCE. Key anchors you can audit - Starting TCE and TBVPS (3Q’25): TCE ≈ $171.3B; TBVPS ≈ $95.72; shares ≈ 1.789B. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/citigroup-third-quarter-2025-press-release-ce7d5ad9df80f225?utm_source=openai)) - Cost of equity: Base 9.0% (10‑year ~4.0% in mid‑October plus ~5% equity risk premium). We also test 8.5% and 10.0%. ([ycharts.com](https://ycharts.com/indicators/10_year_treasury_rate_h15?utm_source=openai)) - ROTCE trajectory: - Reported ROTCE ~8–9% in 2025 with improving mix; management/analysts point to 10–11% by 2026 as simplification benefits flow. We model a glide from 10.5% in 2026 toward 10.0% by 2030 in base; a 12% peak in bull; flat 9% in bear. ([investopedia.com](https://www.investopedia.com/citi-earnings-q2-fy2025-11769905?utm_source=openai)) - Capital returns and share count: Large 2025 buyback authorization and rising dividend; we hold TCE roughly flat in the base case (retained earnings ≈ buybacks), conservative given TBVPS has been trending up. ([investing.com](https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/citigroup-q2-2025-presentation-revenue-jumps-8-announces-20b-buyback-93CH-4135508?utm_source=openai)) ### Residual‑income DCF (billions; per‑share uses 1.789B shares) Assumptions - Base: r=9.0%; ROTCE path 10.5% (2026) → 10.75% (2027) → 10.5% → 10.25% → 10.0%; TCE held ~flat at $171.3B; terminal ROTCE 9.5%. - Bull: r=8.5%; ROTCE 11.0% (2026) → 12.0% (2027) → 11.5% → 11.0% → 10.5%; terminal 10.5%. - Bear: r=10.0%; ROTCE = 9% for 5 years; terminal 9%. Step‑by‑step (excess return each year = (ROTCE − r) × TCE; PV factors from r): 1) Compute yearly excess returns (see assumptions above). 2) Discount 5 years of excess returns. 3) Terminal value = terminal excess return / r (zero growth conservatism), discounted back 5 years. 4) Intrinsic equity value = TCE today + PV(5y excess) + PV(Terminal). 5) Per‑share = Equity value / shares. Results - Base: PV of 5‑year excess ≈ $9.5B; PV of terminal ≈ $6.2B; Equity ≈ $171.3 + $9.5 + $6.2 ≈ $187.0B → ≈ $104–$105/share. - Bull: PV(5y) ≈ $18.5B; PV(Terminal) ≈ $26.9B; Equity ≈ $216.7B → ≈ $121/share. - Bear: Excess ≈ $0; Equity ≈ TCE ≈ $171.3B → ≈ $95–$96/share. Reality check against price - Today’s price ≈ $100.99; our base ~$104–$105 suggests modest upside with a clear floor near TBVPS (~$96) if returns stall, and meaningful upside ($120+) if ROTCE reaches/sustains low‑teens with buybacks. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/citigroup-third-quarter-2025-press-release-ce7d5ad9df80f225?utm_source=openai)) ### Comparable valuation - Price / TBVPS today: Citi ~1.05x; Bank of America ~1.87x (price ~$53.02; TBVPS ~$28.39); JPMorgan likely ≥2.8x (price ~$304; TBVPS ~$105.7); Wells Fargo ~2.0x (price ~$87; TBVPS ~$44.2). Citi remains discounted to the big‑bank group. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/bank-of-america-3rd-quarter-results-ce7d5adfda81fe2d?utm_source=openai)) Notes on comps - The premium at JPM/WFC reflects higher, sustained ROTCE targets; Citi’s discount should narrow if it demonstrates consistent 10–11% ROTCE and keeps lifting TBVPS via buybacks. ([reuters.com](https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/wells-fargo-profit-rises-higher-interest-income-2025-10-14/?utm_source=openai)) --- ## What must go right vs. base Upside drivers - Execution: deliver 10–11% ROTCE by 2026 via expense control, Services growth, and steadier Markets/Banking activity; sustain large buybacks authorized in 2025. ([cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/15/citigroup-c-earnings-q2-2025.html?utm_source=openai)) - Footprint simplification: Banamex sell‑down/IPO reduces earnings volatility and capital drag. ([reuters.com](https://www.reuters.com/business/finance/citigroup-profit-climbs-record-revenue-while-mexico-sale-drags-2025-10-14/?utm_source=openai)) Downside risks - Macro and rates: a sharp downturn or credit losses in U.S. cards (USPB) would pressure earnings; if the 10‑year rises materially, cost of equity climbs. Current 10‑year is near ~4.0% in mid‑October. ([ycharts.com](https://ycharts.com/indicators/10_year_treasury_rate_h15?utm_source=openai)) - Execution risk: transformation/controls and global repositioning (including China headcount actions) could take longer or cost more than planned. ([ft.com](https://www.ft.com/content/a983096c-073d-486e-b1f6-2884b8cc1802?utm_source=openai)) --- ## Investment view and valuation range - Residual‑income DCF range: ~$95 (bear, TBV floor) to ~$121 (bull), with a base around ~$104–$105 per share. - At ~$101 today, the skew is favorable but not extreme. We’d characterize Citi as an “Accumulate on dips near TBVPS” value idea, with upside if ROTCE crosses and sustains double digits while TBVPS climbs. Watch quarterly ROTCE, TBVPS growth, expense ratio, and net share count. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/citigroup-third-quarter-2025-press-release-ce7d5ad9df80f225?utm_source=openai)) --- ## How we built the valuation (steps, fully sourced) 1) Establish today’s equity base - Pulled Q3’25 TCE ($171.3B), TBVPS (~$95.72), and share count (~1.789B). These set the “book value floor.” ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/citigroup-third-quarter-2025-press-release-ce7d5ad9df80f225?utm_source=openai)) 2) Set the discount rate - Used a 9.0% base cost of equity with the 10‑year around ~4.0% mid‑October 2025; sensitized 8.5–10.0% to reflect rate volatility. ([ycharts.com](https://ycharts.com/indicators/10_year_treasury_rate_h15?utm_source=openai)) 3) Build the return path - Anchored ROTCE near 8–9% in 2025 and glide to 10–11% in 2026 per management/analyst commentary; created base/bull/bear spreads vs. cost of equity. ([cnbc.com](https://www.cnbc.com/2025/07/15/citigroup-c-earnings-q2-2025.html?utm_source=openai)) 4) Project excess returns and discount - Computed (ROTCE − r) × TCE each year for five years; conservatively held TCE roughly flat (retention ≈ buybacks) despite TBVPS trending up. ([gurufocus.com](https://www.gurufocus.com/news/2978430/citigroup-inc-c-q2-2025-earnings-eps-of-196-and-revenue-of-217-billion-surpass-estimates?utm_source=openai)) 5) Terminal treatment - Used a zero‑growth perpetuity on terminal excess returns (conservative for banks) and discounted back; added to today’s TCE to get equity value. 6) Sanity‑check with comps - Benchmarked P/TBV vs. JPM/BAC/WFC and confirmed Citi’s relative discount. ([investing.com](https://www.investing.com/news/company-news/jpmorgan-q3-2025-slides-net-income-jumps-12-yoy-despite-market-challenges-93CH-4286846?utm_source=openai)) --- ## Bottom line - Citi remains a credible value candidate with a visible plan, strong capital, and rising TBVPS. On our work, intrinsic value clusters just above today’s price with a logical floor near TBVPS and upside toward ~$120 if ROTCE improves on schedule and buybacks continue. We’d accumulate closer to tangible book (~$96) and hold for a re‑rating as returns converge on targets. ([marketscreener.com](https://www.marketscreener.com/news/citigroup-third-quarter-2025-press-release-ce7d5ad9df80f225?utm_source=openai)) --- ## Appendix: Rate/price context and recent Citi datapoints - 10‑year U.S. Treasury near ~4.0% in October 2025; we used this to calibrate cost of equity. ([ycharts.com](https://ycharts.com/indicators/10_year_treasury_rate_h15?utm_source=openai)) - Citi price today (Oct 28, 2025): ~$100.99. - Q2’25: Revenue $21.7B, EPS $1.96, raised FY’25 revenue guide; Q3’25: net income +16% y/y despite Banamex stake‑sale loss; TBVPS increased to ~$95.72; shares declined to ~1.789B. ([gurufocus.com](https://www.gurufocus.com/news/2978430/citigroup-inc-c-q2-2025-earnings-eps-of-196-and-revenue-of-217-billion-surpass-estimates?utm_source=openai)) If you want, I can share the exact residual‑income model sheet so you can tweak ROTCE, cost of equity, and terminal assumptions, and see how buyback pace alters per‑share value.