Design Wisdom: Less, More, and the Middle Ground

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: Paula Scher — “Less is more and more is more. It’s the middle that’s not a good place.”[1]

Graphic design is a language with vocabulary, rules, and structure—ideas strike instantly through play and intuition.[2][3]

Pentagram partner Paula Scher challenges design dogma: good design shuns mediocre averages, embracing bold extremes—sparse minimalism for piercing clarity or dense maximalism for immersive depth—to create work that resonates and endures.[1]

Chew on this

  • Bold commitment: Minimal strips to essence; maximal layers for richness—middle muddles both.[1]
  • Playful intuition: Enter a "state of play" for instinctive breakthroughs, not overthought tweaks.[3]
  • Long-term punch: Designs must communicate instantly, evolve identity, and demand no proof beyond perception.[3]

Try this today (Mediocrity Audit)

  1. Pick artifact: Choose a product, UI, or graphic you're refining.
  2. Spot the middle: Note bland balances—neither sparse nor rich.
  3. Push extremes: Strip to bare essentials or amplify layers; test which amplifies impact.[1]

Sources