Redefining Good Design: From Aesthetics to Action

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: Herbert Simon

“Everyone designs who devises courses of action aimed at changing existing situations into preferred ones.” — Herbert A. Simon, The Sciences of the Artificial

Simon shifts the question from “What looks good?” to “What makes a situation more preferred?” Good design is thus disciplined preference-making under constraint: clarifying values, surfacing trade‑offs, and steering reality toward them. Aesthetics matter, but only as they serve a chosen better.

Why this matters

  • Preference precedes polish. Without a clear definition of “preferred,” refinement is just ornament.
  • Design is judgment under constraint. Choices allocate attention, time, risk, and resources—not just pixels.
  • Framing is half the craft. Reframing the problem often changes what “better” even means.

Put it to work

  1. Write the preference: “In two weeks, success means X for Y people because Z.”
  2. Expose trade‑offs: list what you’re willing to worsen to improve the target outcome.
  3. Set decision tests: 3 criteria that any option must satisfy; kill what doesn’t.
  4. Prototype the preference: a minimal scenario that proves the “preferred” is actually preferable.
  5. Track regret: after launch, note what you’d undo; refine the preference statement, not just the solution.

Further exploration: Herbert A. Simon’s “The Sciences of the Artificial” book.