Designing Justice: Insights from John Rawls

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: John Rawls — Design Behind the Veil

“The principles of justice are chosen behind a veil of ignorance.” — John Rawls, A Theory of Justice. (plato.stanford.edu)

Rawls’ deep take: fair systems emerge when decision‑makers don’t know which role they’ll occupy. Translate that to design: set defaults, rules, and failure states as if you might be the least‑advantaged user—the one with the slowest connection, least money, lowest vision, newest skills, or least power. If your interface, pricing, privacy, and recovery flows would still feel fair and dignified from that position, you’re closer to “justice as fairness” in product form. (plato.stanford.edu)

Try a quick “veil check” today:

  • Hide privilege in your specs: assume you don’t know the user’s device, bandwidth, eyesight, dexterity, wealth, or status. Would any current choices exploit those facts? Fix them. (plato.stanford.edu)
  • Reframe trade‑offs: when an inequality exists (e.g., premium features), ensure it clearly benefits the least‑advantaged user too (support, access, or safety), not just the top tier. (plato.stanford.edu)
  • Design failure mercy: rate‑limit penalties, generous undo, transparent appeal paths—because you might be the one who taps the wrong button on a shaky train. (plato.stanford.edu)

Good design isn’t merely usable; it’s principled. Build as if you don’t know who you’ll be when you meet your product.

—

Sources