Embrace Character: The Case Against Homogeneous Design
What Is Good Design?
Today’s Lens: Nick Foster — “Good design has now become synonymous with invisible design, but by removing every point of difference, we have removed any notion of character.”[1]
In a sharp 2026 critique, Figma's design leader Nick Foster calls out software's homogenized, "joyless" sameness—apps that all feel identical despite engineering feats. With AI's rise, he urges designers to embrace the tech's quirks, friction, and unpredictability as a raw material for fresh, characterful experiences.[1]
Chew on this
- Sameness trap: Streamlined interfaces erase brand uniqueness and emotional grip, turning miracles of logic into "underwhelming" daily tools.[1]
- AI as ally: Treat probabilistic AI like a quirky amp—lean into its "stochastic" flaws for novel interactions, not forced efficiency.[1]
- Friction's value: Not all needs speed; design for negotiation, doubt, and delightful instability to spark curiosity.[1]
Try this today (Foster Character Audit)
- Spot the mid: List 3 apps/tools feeling "optimized but joyless"—note erased differences.[1]
- Probe quirks: Test an AI tool for inconsistencies; sketch ways to amplify them into features.[1]
- Add seam: Prototype one "seam" or pause—test if it boosts grip or intrigue.[1]