Value Radar: Fresh Insights on Intercontinental Exchange
Value Radar: Fresh Picks & A Full Valuation Deep‑Dive on Intercontinental Exchange (ICE)
Date: November 2, 2025 (United States)
This research is for educational purposes only, not investment advice. Every key assumption is sourced so you can audit it.
10 fresh value candidates (quick scan)
Intercontinental Exchange (ICE) — diversified market infrastructure (NYSE, energy/financial futures, mortgage tech, fixed‑income/data). 2024 set records for revenue, operating income and adjusted free cash flow; 2025 year‑to‑date results remain strong. Dividend was lifted 7% early‑2025. New optionality from a planned investment of up to $2B in Polymarket. We deep‑dive below. (ir.theice.com)
CME Group (CME) — volume leverage to rates/volatility; Q3‑25 data revenue hit a record; balance sheet conservative; ongoing hefty regular plus variable dividends. Valuation richer than peers but quality high. (cmegroup.com)
McKesson (MCK) — durable distributor with oncology ecosystem expansion; FY25 EPS guidance raised and buybacks stepped up. Cash conversion remains robust though FCF is seasonally lumpy. (mckesson.com)
Cencora (COR) — formerly AmerisourceBergen; updated FY25 outlook calls for higher adj. EPS and operating income growth, with steady high‑single‑digit revenue gains. Specialty pharma scale is a plus. (investor.cencora.com)
LyondellBasell (LYB) — cyclical chemicals at through‑cycle value; watch cost actions and downstream mix. (Context: industry still under pressure; stock selection hinges on capital returns discipline.) (apnews.com)
Dow (DOW) — reset dividend lower in July to protect flexibility through a prolonged downturn; closing high‑cost European assets to improve structural economics. Not “easy” value, but actions increase long‑term odds. (investors.dow.com)
Marsh McLennan (MMC) — high‑quality insurance brokerage/consulting with double‑digit EPS growth and buybacks; Q3‑25 showed broad‑based strength. Defensive cash generator, typically at a premium multiple. (tipranks.com)
Bank of America (BAC) — scale deposit franchise and expense work; value hinges on the rate path and credit. (Peer datapoint: WFC’s cap removal in June lifted ROTCE targets, illustrating sector re‑rating potential if constraints ease.) (reuters.com)
Wells Fargo (WFC) — asset cap reportedly lifted in June; higher ROTCE targets and improving fee momentum. Still regulatory overhang risk, but valuation remains below top‑quality peers. (reuters.com)
Cboe Global Markets (CBOE) — diversified derivatives/indices/data; valuation sits between ICE and CME; operating leverage to options ADV and volatility. (multiples.vc)
Pick of the edition: Intercontinental Exchange (ICE)
A resilient cash compounder across exchanges, data, and mortgage technology. We build a bottom‑up valuation and test where today’s price sits versus intrinsic value.
What’s new — why now
Record 2024 performance: net revenues $9.3B (+16% y/y), record operating income and adjusted FCF “over $3.6B.” ICE resumed repurchases and hiked the dividend 7% to $0.48/quarter in early 2025. (ir.theice.com)
Strong 2025 trajectory: Q1 posted record net revenues and record adjusted EPS; Q2 delivered record revenue with energy strength; Q3 again beat on EPS with segment growth in Fixed Income & Data Services and Mortgage Tech. Management returned >$1.7B to holders through September. (ir.theice.com)
Added optionality: ICE plans to invest up to $2B in Polymarket, positioning for event markets/data. Financial impact in 2025 is expected to be immaterial, but strategic optionality is notable. (reuters.com)
Guidance and cash: 2024 operating cash flow was $4.6B; adjusted FCF “over $3.6B.” 2025 capex guide is ~$0.73–$0.78B; through Q2‑25, OCF was ~$2.5B and adjusted FCF ~$2.0B. (ir.theice.com)
Business in one page
Segments: Exchanges (NYSE + futures, especially energy/financial), Fixed Income & Data Services (pricing, evaluated pricing, analytics, ICE Bonds), and Mortgage Technology (Encompass origination + Black Knight servicing/data integration). In 2024, Exchanges net revenue was ~$5.0B (+12%); Fixed Income & Data achieved record $2.3B; Mortgage Technology was ~$2.0B with rising recurring revenue. (ir.theice.com)
Economic engine: high recurring revenue in data/indices/servicing; operating leverage to volatility/volumes in energy and rates; mortgage cycle recovery adds cyclical upside as rates normalize. (reuters.com)
Ground‑up valuation
We anchor on Free Cash Flow to Equity (FCFE) from primary releases and cross‑checks, then run a DCF and a comps check.
Step 1) Establish FCFE baseline
Reported cash metrics:
- 2024 operating cash flow: ~$4.6B; adjusted free cash flow: “over $3.6B.” (ir.theice.com)
- 2025 YTD through Q2: OCF ~$2.5B; adjusted FCF ~$2.0B. Q3 commentary shows continued strength. (ir.theice.com)
- Independent data shows TTM FCF around $4.4B by June 2025 (directionally consistent with ICE’s record 2024 cash figures). We use this only as a cross‑check. (businessquant.com)
Capex context: 2025 capex guide ~$0.73–$0.78B (consistent with 2024’s ~$0.7–$0.74B run‑rate). (markets.financialcontent.com)
Shares outstanding: ~575–577M in 2025; we model with 575M for per‑share math. (macrotrends.net)
Our base FCFE (2025E): $4.2B. Rationale: sits between 2024 adjusted FCF (> $3.6B) and TTM indications by mid‑2025 (~$4.4B), and squares with strong YTD cash generation plus normalized capex. Sensitivity below tests ±10% around this anchor. (ir.theice.com)
Step 2) Cost of equity and terminal growth
U.S. 10‑year Treasury: 4.12% for September 2025. We bracket cost of equity at 8.0%–9.5% to reflect macro uncertainty and ICE’s quality/scale. Base case: 8.5%–9.0%. (ycharts.com)
Terminal growth: 2.0%–2.25% (long‑run, real‑plus‑inflation consistent with mature financial infrastructure). No reliance on Polymarket upside in base case.
Step 3) 5‑year FCFE path (explicit period)
- Base case growth: 4.5% CAGR (blended: mid‑single growth in data/analytics, mortgage recovery tailwind, steady exchange activity). Cross‑reference: ICE raised/affirmed 2025 recurring growth assumptions (e.g., mid‑single digits in Fixed Income & Data) and posted record results YTD. (ir.theice.com)
Illustrative trajectory (billions):
- Year 1: $4.39
- Year 2: $4.59
- Year 3: $4.80
- Year 4: $5.02
- Year 5: $5.25
Step 4) DCF math (FCFE)
- Discount rate (r): 8.5% base; terminal growth (g): 2.25%.
- Present value of 5‑year FCFE ≈ $19.0B–$20.0B (range across 8.5%–9.0% r).
- Terminal value at Year 5 ≈ $90B–$95B; PV ≈ $58B–$61B.
- Equity value ≈ $77B–$81B.
- Per share (575M) ≈ $134–$141.
Key sensitivities (per share):
- r = 8.0%, 5‑yr FCFE CAGR 5.0%, g = 2.25% → ≈ $142–$148
- r = 9.0%, 5‑yr FCFE CAGR 4.0%, g = 2.0% → ≈ $128–$133
At a recent market cap ~ $96B (late‑Sep snapshot; shares ~$167), our base DCF implies the stock trades above a conservative intrinsic value based on today’s stand‑alone cash engine and discount‑rate backdrop. In other words, quality is priced. (stockanalysis.com)
Step 5) Comparable checks
- EV/EBITDA:
- ICE ≈ 16.9x TTM (Jun‑25). (gurufocus.com)
- CME ≈ 16.8x–21.9x depending on source/date; premium reflects rate‑cycle torque and variable dividend policy. (tipranks.com)
- Cboe ≈ 16.9x–19.8x. (multiples.vc)
- Nasdaq (NDAQ) EV/EBIT proxy in mid‑20s, reflecting mix shift to software/data. (gurufocus.com)
Interpretation: ICE trades below CME on some days but above CBOE on others, and well below NDAQ’s software‑heavy multiple — reasonable given ICE’s balanced mix. On FCF yield using our $4.2B base, equity FCF yield is roughly 4.2%–4.5% against a ~4.1% 10‑year — not screamingly cheap on a spread basis. (ycharts.com)
Cross‑checks on assumptions
Cash flow base: anchored to ICE’s 2024 OCF ($4.6B) and adjusted FCF (> $3.6B), plus mid‑2025 run‑rate disclosures and third‑party TTM tracking around $4.4B. We deliberately model at $4.2B to avoid over‑crediting volatile transaction revenues. (ir.theice.com)
Growth: supported by 2025 guidance (mid‑single‑digit recurring growth in Fixed Income & Data; low‑single in Exchanges recurring; low‑to‑mid single in Mortgage Tech) and strong first‑half results; we use a blended 4.5% FCFE CAGR. (markets.financialcontent.com)
Discount rate: bracketed using the current Treasury backdrop; we do not assume a sharp fall in the risk‑free rate. (ycharts.com)
Verdict
One‑liner: ICE is a high‑quality, “all‑weather” cash compounding platform with durable moats in energy benchmarks, NYSE, fixed‑income data, and a mortgage stack that should benefit as housing volumes normalize. But at ~4%–4.5% equity FCF yield against a 10‑year near ~4.1%, this is quality at a fair‑to‑full price, not classic deep value.
Valuation range (stand‑alone): $128–$148 per share on our DCF sensitivity set (midpoint ≈ $138). At recent quotes around the mid‑$160s in late September, the market is discounting either a lower effective cost of equity, higher sustainable FCFE growth, or some probability of incremental optionality (e.g., new products/data, Polymarket). (stockanalysis.com)
What could change our mind upward:
- Evidence of sustainable FCFE >$4.6–$4.8B with mid‑single growth sticking into 2027–2028. (ir.theice.com)
- Clear monetization of new event/data adjacencies without regulatory friction (Polymarket‑linked). (reuters.com)
- A lower risk‑free rate backdrop closer to 3.5% that reduces the equity discount rate. (ycharts.com)
What could push value down:
- Prolonged low mortgage activity delaying the recovery of transaction revenues. (ir.theice.com)
- Lower energy/rates volatility compressing exchange transaction income. (reuters.com)
- Higher for longer yields, keeping the discount rate elevated. (ycharts.com)
Action: Hold/Watchlist for value investors. Accumulate on pullbacks that offer a 6%+ equity FCF yield (implies a price closer to the high‑$120s to low‑$140s on our $4.2B FCFE base) or on evidence that sustainable FCFE is stepping up above our base case.
Why some “value” chatter can be off here
“It’s cheap vs. peers.” Not really. ICE at ~17x EV/EBITDA sits below CME at times but around Cboe and far below NDAQ for good reasons tied to mix. On FCF yield, the spread over Treasuries is thin. (gurufocus.com)
“Mortgage will snap back fast.” It may recover, but management’s guidance frames low‑to‑mid single‑digit growth for Mortgage Tech — a steady rebuild, not a spike. (markets.financialcontent.com)
Appendix: our step‑by‑step modeling notes
Gathered the latest GAAP/Non‑GAAP and cash metrics from ICE’s 2024 wrap‑up and 2025 Q1–Q3 updates; cross‑checked TTM FCF and shares outstanding from third‑party trackers. (ir.theice.com)
Set FCFE(2025E) at $4.2B, consistent with record 2024 cash generation, YTD 2025 FCF run‑rate, capex guidance, and segment momentum. (ir.theice.com)
Discount rate anchored to the current 10‑year (4.12%) with a quality premium; tested 8.0%–9.5%. (ycharts.com)
Modeled a conservative 4.5% 5‑year FCFE CAGR and 2.25% terminal growth; computed PV of explicit period and terminal; divided by ~575M shares to get per‑share ranges. (macrotrends.net)
Cross‑checked with comps (EV/EBITDA bands) for sanity. (gurufocus.com)
If you want one “buy today” from this list
Among exchange peers, Cboe’s multiple sits below CME and often close to ICE while retaining operating leverage to index/options growth; for deep value purists in financials, Wells Fargo’s cap removal and ROTCE target lift create a clearer self‑help runway if you can underwrite residual regulatory risk. As always, price discipline matters. (multiples.vc)
If you’d like, I can share a compact spreadsheet so you can flex discount rates, growth, and FCFE to see how the per‑share value moves.