Unlocking Creativity: The Power of Bad Ideas
The Daily Interesting — Art & Design Edition
March 26, 2026
The idea
I use a trick with co-workers when we’re trying to decide where to eat for lunch and no one has any ideas. I recommend McDonald’s.
An interesting thing happens. Everyone unanimously agrees that we can’t possibly go to McDonald’s, and better lunch suggestions emerge. Magic!
It’s as if we’ve broken the ice with the worst possible idea, and now that the discussion has started, people suddenly get very creative. I call it the McDonald’s Theory: people are inspired to come up with good ideas to ward off bad ones.[1][2]
— Jon Bell (BarnsworthBurning extract)[1]
Who said it (and the context)
Jon Bell is a designer, writer, and former product manager (notably at Rdio) known for his witty, practical essays on creativity and teamwork. This idea comes from his 2013 Medium post, born from real-world office indecision—using a deliberately terrible suggestion to jolt stagnant group brainstorming into action.[2][3]
A small expansion
Bell's theory flips creativity blocks: by voicing the worst option first, it disarms perfectionism, sparks rejection-fueled alternatives, and kickstarts momentum—proving extremes can unlock the imagination faster than polite vagueness.[1]
Another lens on the idea
The design world's "Worst Possible Idea" exercise takes this further: teams deliberately brainstorm awful solutions (e.g., a website that crashes instantly) to build psychological safety, then flip them into gems—echoing Bell but formalized for ideation sessions, as championed by the Interaction Design Foundation.[4]
Why this matters across art and design
Visual identity
Stuck on a logo? Pitch a garish, cliché version first—watch the team rally to refine something sharp and original.[1]Product & UX
Propose a clunky, frustrating flow (endless pop-ups?); contrasts reveal intuitive paths, energizing prototypes.[1]Architecture
Suggest impractical extremes (a skyscraper of glass boxes?); group pushback hones feasible, harmonious structures.[1]Studio art
Sketch your "worst" composition (mud-splattered chaos); negation sparks deliberate, evocative marks.[1]
Two quick drills
McNugget Kickoff (5 minutes)
In a solo or team huddle, name the worst option for your current challenge (e.g., Comic Sans logo). List 5 better rebuttals—what emerges?[1]Bad-to-Brilliant Flip (10 minutes)
Brainstorm 7 intentionally terrible ideas for a project element. Vote worst, then mutate it twice toward viable. Note the sparks.[4]
Thread to remember
Ties Gombrich's artist activities (52) to squiggle messiness (39), where "bad" starts fuel iteration—like beginner's load-path (3), verb drills (4), and worst-failure forms (19). Negation as constraint (1,18) cultivates playful, emergent craft over polished paralysis.
Sources
- Central idea/quote: Jon Bell via BarnsworthBurning (extract); original Medium (post).[1][2]
- Bell background: Medium author; refs Dave Redfern.[3]
- Lens: IxDF: Worst Possible Idea.[4]
Try this today: Pitch your project's McDonald's—what magic rejects it?