Reimagining Problems: Art of Representation
The Daily Interesting — Art & Design Edition
April 07, 2026
Problem-Solving as Perfect Representation
The idea
The representation of a task can radically affect our reasoning abilities and performance. For example, the game of tic-tac-toe (opposing players mark X's and O's in a 3x3 grid) can be equivalently represented as a game of drawing numbered cards with the goal of selecting three that sum to 15. From a computational perspective, these two problems are isomorphic. However, the tic-tac-toe representation is significantly easier to work with because the representational form of the problem makes visible the most relevant constraints implicit in the problem. As Simon writes, in mathematics, "solving a problem simply means representing a problem so as to make the solution transparent."[1][2]
— Herbert A. Simon (BarnsworthBurning extract)[1]
Who said it (and the context)
Herbert A. Simon (1916–2001) was a pioneering polymath—a professor of computer science, psychology, and economics at Carnegie Mellon University. He won the Nobel Prize in Economics (1978) for bounded rationality and decision-making theories, and the Turing Award (1975) for AI contributions. In The Sciences of the Artificial and Human Problem Solving (with Allen Newell), Simon explored how minds tackle complex tasks, using the tic-tac-toe vs. "number scrabble" (a 3x3 magic square summing to 15) to show identical problems feel worlds apart based on how they're framed. This insight, quoted in interaction design papers, underscores design's core: crafting artifacts that shape human thought.[3][4][2]
A small expansion
Simon reveals design's magic: the right representation doesn't just describe a problem—it exposes its hidden structure, constraints, and paths forward, turning confusion into clarity. Tic-tac-toe wins because the grid shows winning lines instantly; cards hide them. In art and design, this means prioritizing forms that illuminate intent, whether a minimalist icon or layered UI.[1][5]
Another lens on the idea
Bret Victor echoes this in his "Ladder of Abstraction": designers climb between raw data/examples and high-level principles, choosing views that make ideas tangible and explorable—like zooming from pixels to patterns. Poor reps obscure; great ones invite discovery, blending Simon's transparency with dynamic interplay.[6]
Why this matters across art and design
Visual identity
Logos as "grids": craft marks revealing brand constraints (e.g., modularity) at a glance, like tic-tac-toe lines signaling scalability.[1]Product & UX
Interfaces expose states/logic: dashboards as visible puzzles, where user paths (flows) mirror winning strategies, reducing cognitive load.[1]Architecture
Plans/sections as transparent reps: sectional diagrams unveil spatial tensions better than renders, guiding intuitive navigation.[1]Studio art
Compositions frame viewer problems: asymmetry or grids that show perceptual tensions, sparking emergent insights.[1]
Two quick drills
Rep Swap Sprint (15 minutes)
Pick tic-tac-toe or a logo sketch. Redraw in 3 reps: grid, cards/list, network diagram. Which reveals strategy/core fastest? Apply to your work.[1][2]Transparency Test (20 minutes)
Abstract a project problem (e.g., UI flow) into a simple diagram vs. screenshot. Share—does the diagram make solutions pop? Iterate.[1]
Thread to remember
Links representation to tool grains (29,50), perceptual reawakening (32), form-from-failure (11), state mapping (46), clarity tests (49), and squiggle refinement (31)—elevating how we frame chaos into coherent beauty, kin to grid constraints (52) and medium dialogues (34).
Sources
- Central idea/representation: BarnsworthBurning (How Bodies Matter extract); Simon's Sciences of the Artificial (PDF); Human Problem Solving (ref).[1][4][2]
- Simon background: Science of Design (PDF).[3]
- Victor lens: BarnsworthBurning (Bret Victor creator).[6]
Try this today: Grab a thorny design—what rep makes it solvable?