Crafting Software: Embracing Materials Over Features

Title: Designing with Materials, Not Features: Linus Lee on Software as a Creative Medium

Some software interfaces are windows into collections of features. ... For software like Figma, Apple Notes, and the humble file explorer, there aren’t such clearly defined tasks... Instead, these apps present the user with materials and clear laws of physics governing how those materials behave.

The idea
Linus Lee proposes shifting from feature-driven interfaces—grids of buttons and menus that prescribe specific actions—to material-driven ones, where users interact with consistent “substances” governed by their own simple rules. In a material interface, shapes in Figma or text strokes in a notes app behave according to internal physics: they can be moved, layered, resized, or combined in open-ended ways. The result is software that feels less like a vending machine of tasks and more like a studio or workshop—inviting exploration, improvisation, and emergent possibilities rather than locking users into predefined paths.[1]

Who said it (and the context)
Linus Lee is a builder and writer focused on tools for thought, personal knowledge systems, and the future of creative software. His essays on thesephist.com explore how digital environments shape thinking and making. The idea appears on Barnsworth Burning as part of Lee’s broader reflections on interfaces that support open-ended creativity rather than scripted workflows.[2]

A small expansion
Feature lists work well for narrow, goal-oriented apps (call a car, search the web). But in open creative work—visual identity systems, product interfaces, architectural visualizations, or studio art practice—users rarely know the exact sequence of actions in advance. Materials let them discover new combinations on the fly. A single “material” (a vector shape, a text block, a commit in Git) multiplies possibilities exponentially when combined with others, much like physical pigments or clay. The maker learns a compact set of rules instead of memorizing hierarchies, then keeps discovering new uses long after the initial encounter. This mirrors the newsletter’s ongoing emphasis on attentive making: the interface itself becomes a responsive partner rather than a rigid instruction set.

Another lens on the idea
John Palmer’s writing on spatial software offers a complementary view. Palmer defines spatial interfaces by the free movement of bodies and objects under real-world-like rules (Figma’s canvas or Second Life’s environment). Lee broadens the concept beyond literal space to any consistent “material” with its own physics—commits in Git, clips on a video timeline—even when no obvious 3-D metaphor is present. Both reject top-down feature catalogs in favor of bottom-up emergence. Where Palmer highlights spatial relationships, Lee emphasizes the combinatorial power of well-behaved substances. Together they point toward interfaces that feel inhabitable and alive rather than merely operable.

Why this matters across art and design

  • Visual identity: A logo system built from a few core marks and rules (materials) can generate endless coherent variations without new “features” for every application.
  • Product & UX: Tools like Figma or code editors succeed because users manipulate shapes, text, or components directly; new workflows appear through combination rather than menu additions.
  • Architecture: Parametric or generative tools thrive when designers work with material behaviors (light, mass, repetition) instead of isolated commands.
  • Studio art: Digital drawing or 3-D modeling apps feel most alive when the medium itself has consistent physics that reward play and surprise.

Two quick drills

  1. Material Inventory (10 minutes)
    Open a familiar creative app. List the core “materials” it offers (shapes, text, layers, commits, clips). Note the simple rules each obeys. Ask: Does the interface feel like manipulating these substances, or like choosing from a menu of features?

  2. Material Remix Sketch (15 minutes)
    Take one existing element in your current project. Redesign it as if it were a material with three clear rules of behavior. Sketch or prototype two unexpected combinations that the rules naturally allow but the original interface doesn’t explicitly support.

Thread to remember
This edition extends the newsletter’s theme of attentive making into the digital realm: when tools are built from responsive materials rather than fixed features, the dialogue between maker and medium becomes richer, more surprising, and more personal. It connects to earlier explorations of workmanship of risk, unfolding processes, and direct manipulation—each a call to stay in honest, embodied conversation with what we make.

Sources

  • Central idea drawn from Linus Lee’s “Design with materials, not features” via Barnsworth Burning.
  • Complementary perspective informed by John Palmer’s writing on spatial software (referenced in the same piece).
  • Supporting context from Lee’s related essays on tools for thought and navigation.

Try this today: In your next digital sketch, layout, or prototype, pause and ask: “What materials am I actually working with, and what simple rules do they follow?” Adjust the interface (or your approach) to let those materials do more of the work.