Redefining Good Design: Function Over Aesthetics

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: Bob Gill — “There is no good. The good comes from what does the job. Once it might be a sunset, which is beautiful, and another might be a dog turd, which is disgusting. But it may be the perfect image for what you’re trying to communicate.”[1]

Graphic design pioneer and Pentagram co-founder Bob Gill delivers a radical truth: good design defies fixed standards of beauty, defined solely by job fulfillment in context—prioritizing communication over convention.[1]

Chew on this

  • Purpose over prettiness: Effectiveness trumps aesthetics; the "right" visual serves the message, no matter its look.[1]
  • Challenge cultural bias: We're conditioned against novelty—true originality risks "ugly" but wins by working.[1]
  • Context is king: A shocking image can outperform elegance if it lands the intent perfectly.[1]

Try this today (Gill Job-Fit Audit)

  1. Select a design task (ad, UI icon): List goals—what must it achieve?[1]
  2. Generate extremes: Sketch "beautiful" vs. "disgusting" options; test for communication impact.[1]
  3. Measure results: Poll users on clarity/engagement; keep what does the job best.[1]

Sources