Designing in Context: Embracing Messy Reality
What Is Good Design?
Today’s Lens: Lucy Suchman — Plans as Resources, Not Scripts
“Plans are resources for situated action, but do not in any strong sense determine its course.” (vdoc.pub)
Suchman’s deep claim: real use unfolds in context—messy, contingent, full of micro‑judgments. Plans, checklists, and flows aren’t blueprints that control behavior; they’re aids people consult and continually reinterpret while acting. Good design embraces this situated-ness: it equips users to adapt in the moment, recover from surprises, and make sense of what’s happening—without forcing brittle, over‑specified paths. (resolve.cambridge.org)
Chew on this
- Design for improvisation. Treat procedures, hints, and guardrails as “orientation devices,” not mandatory funnels. Make the best path obvious but the alternatives possible. (resolve.cambridge.org)
- Move help into the action. Surface examples, previews, and “why this matters” exactly where the user decides—so they can repurpose guidance mid‑stream. (resolve.cambridge.org)
- Judge by resilience, not only completion. Measure time‑to‑recovery, graceful divergence from the “happy path,” and clarity of local feedback. (resolve.cambridge.org)
Try this today (3‑minute “situatedness” pass)
- Take one linear flow and add two sanctioned detours: skip, save-for-later, or “edit in place.”
- Replace static help docs with inline, state‑aware tips that appear only when relevant.
- Run a “brittleness drill”: inject a common surprise (missing data, partial info) and redesign the screen so the user can still succeed.
Sources
- Suchman, L. “Situated Actions,” in Human–Machine Reconfigurations. Cambridge University Press. [Chapter PDF] (resolve.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/F4AA82303887FF0875BD656977661875/9780511808418c6_p69-84_CBO.pdf/situated-actions.pdf). (resolve.cambridge.org)
- Suchman, L. Plans and Situated Actions (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press. [Book page] (www.si.edu/object/siris_sil_1053515). (si.edu)
- ECSCW ’91 proceedings quoting Suchman’s formulation. [Proceedings PDF] (vdoc.pub/documents/proceedings-of-the-second-european-conference-on-computer-supported-cooperative-work-ecscw-91-1uv2945cdqoo). (vdoc.pub)
Good design, in Suchman’s frame, is choreography for the unexpected: offer structure that orients—but never shackles—human judgment.