Designing in Context: Embracing Messy Reality

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: Lucy Suchman — Plans as Resources, Not Scripts

“Plans are resources for situated action, but do not in any strong sense determine its course.” (vdoc.pub)

Suchman’s deep claim: real use unfolds in context—messy, contingent, full of micro‑judgments. Plans, checklists, and flows aren’t blueprints that control behavior; they’re aids people consult and continually reinterpret while acting. Good design embraces this situated-ness: it equips users to adapt in the moment, recover from surprises, and make sense of what’s happening—without forcing brittle, over‑specified paths. (resolve.cambridge.org)

Chew on this

  • Design for improvisation. Treat procedures, hints, and guardrails as “orientation devices,” not mandatory funnels. Make the best path obvious but the alternatives possible. (resolve.cambridge.org)
  • Move help into the action. Surface examples, previews, and “why this matters” exactly where the user decides—so they can repurpose guidance mid‑stream. (resolve.cambridge.org)
  • Judge by resilience, not only completion. Measure time‑to‑recovery, graceful divergence from the “happy path,” and clarity of local feedback. (resolve.cambridge.org)

Try this today (3‑minute “situatedness” pass)

  1. Take one linear flow and add two sanctioned detours: skip, save-for-later, or “edit in place.”
  2. Replace static help docs with inline, state‑aware tips that appear only when relevant.
  3. Run a “brittleness drill”: inject a common surprise (missing data, partial info) and redesign the screen so the user can still succeed.

Sources

  • Suchman, L. “Situated Actions,” in Human–Machine Reconfigurations. Cambridge University Press. [Chapter PDF] (resolve.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/F4AA82303887FF0875BD656977661875/9780511808418c6_p69-84_CBO.pdf/situated-actions.pdf). (resolve.cambridge.org)
  • Suchman, L. Plans and Situated Actions (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press. [Book page] (www.si.edu/object/siris_sil_1053515). (si.edu)
  • ECSCW ’91 proceedings quoting Suchman’s formulation. [Proceedings PDF] (vdoc.pub/documents/proceedings-of-the-second-european-conference-on-computer-supported-cooperative-work-ecscw-91-1uv2945cdqoo). (vdoc.pub)

Good design, in Suchman’s frame, is choreography for the unexpected: offer structure that orients—but never shackles—human judgment.