Value Radar: 10 Stocks to Watch Now!

Title: Value Radar: 10 New Ideas, Then a Full Valuation Deep‑Dive on John Deere (DE)

Date: October 26, 2025 (United States)

This research is for educational purposes only, not investment advice. Sources and dates are cited inline so you can audit every key assumption.

Quick scan: 10 fresh value candidates to watch

  • Caterpillar (CAT) — resilient orders and strong cash generation through the cycle; Q2 FY25 operating cash flow $3.1B with $1.5B returned to holders that quarter; margin normalization the debate. (investors.caterpillar.com)
  • IBM (IBM) — old‑line cash machine leaning into AI/automation; now guiding to about $14B FCF for 2025 after an October raise. Dividend discipline intact. (newsroom.ibm.com)
  • Phillips 66 (PSX) — capital‑return story with a long record (>$43B returned since 2012); active portfolio work amid 2025 proxy contest; still emphasizing durable cash returns. (investor.phillips66.com)
  • Rio Tinto (RIO) — cash returns plus copper/Simandou optionality; 1H25 earnings softness on iron ore but project pipeline advancing; interim dividend held at 50% payout policy. (reuters.com)
  • Aflac (AFL) — steady underwriting and buybacks; value vs. quality financials remains reasonable (re‑flagged given rates drift lower). Primary: company IR/filings; rate context below.
  • T. Rowe Price (TROW) — debt‑free, high cash conversion, sensitivity to markets; better flows could re‑rate multiple. Primary: company IR/filings.
  • AGCO (AGCO) — ag‑cycle laggard trading at a discount to large‑cap peers; forward P/E in mid‑teens to ~20x depending on source; execution on tech stack is the swing factor. (stockanalysis.com)
  • CNH Industrial (CNHI) — “iron + tech” plan targets higher margins by 2030; still priced for caution. (barrons.com)
  • Walgreens Boots Alliance (WBA) — deep value with deal risk: shareholders approved a $10B take‑private by Sycamore with contingent value; turnaround levers are store rationalization and cost cuts. (apnews.com)
  • Deere (DE) — the subject of our deep dive below; near‑term cycle down but strong franchise and precision‑ag roadmap; 2025 net income outlook $4.75–$5.25B. (investing.com)

Pick of the edition: John Deere (DE)

Why this is worth a look now

  • Cycle clarity: management narrowed FY25 net income to $4.75–$5.25B on August 14, 2025, acknowledging softer ag/construction but showing discipline on inventory and production. Q2 FY25 EPS beat with $1.804B net income; Q3 showed decelerating demand. (investing.com)
  • Technology roadmap: Deere’s “Smart Industrial” strategy and LEAP ambitions tie autonomy, computer vision, and the Operations Center into higher‑margin lifecycle revenue (parts, services, upgrades). 775k connected machines; 455M “engaged acres.” (s22.q4cdn.com)
  • Rate backdrop: the U.S. 10‑year Treasury yield hovered near ~4.0% in mid‑to‑late October 2025, an anchor for discount rates. (ycharts.com)
  • What the market worries about: tariff costs (~$500M in 2025 est.), weak farm income pressuring large ag, and construction demand normalization. (wsj.com)

Business snapshot and roadmap

  • Segments: Production & Precision Ag (PPA), Small Ag & Turf (SAT), Construction & Forestry (C&F), and Financial Services. In FY2024, PPA ~47% of equipment sales, SAT ~24%, C&F ~29%. (sec.gov)
  • Precision stack: autonomy, machine IQ, computer vision (Blue River), and connectivity (JDLink; Starlink partnership noted); strategy is to lift customer ROI and Deere’s through higher mix and recurring lifecycle revenue. (s22.q4cdn.com)
  • 2025 market tone: Deere guided FY25 PPA sales down ~15–20%, SAT down ~10%, C&F down ~10–15% and kept FY25 net income at $4.75–$5.25B after Q3; company discussed cash flow and tax rate ranges in slides. (investing.com)

What’s new since mid‑year

  • Aug 14, 2025: Q3 EPS beat but outlook narrowed; shares fell on caution about 2H demand; management reiterated inventory discipline. Multiple outlets corroborated the $4.75–$5.25B net income range and segment pressure (PPA most acute). (investopedia.com)
  • Rates drifted toward ~4.0% on the 10‑yr into late October, supporting a somewhat lower equity discount rate than early 2025. (ycharts.com)

Ground‑up valuation: DCF and comps

We value consolidated equity (including Financial Services) using free cash flow to equity (FCFE). Given Deere’s financing arm can make cash flows lumpy, we cross‑reference with management’s 2025 net income and operating cash flow context instead of forcing a granular segment model here.

Key anchors you can audit

  • FY2025 net income outlook: $4.75–$5.25B (midpoint $5.0B). (investing.com)
  • FY2025 slides summarized expected cash items (incl. net operating cash flow $4.5–$5.5B per third‑party coverage of Q3 materials). We treat $5.0B as a conservative “sustainable” FCFE starting point, recognizing working capital/receivables noise around the finance arm. (investing.com)
  • 10‑yr U.S. Treasury: ~4.02% on Oct 24, 2025; we set a 9.0% base cost of equity (rf ~4.0% + ERP/beta cushion), and test 8.5–9.5%. (ycharts.com)
  • Shares outstanding: ~270.3M. Spot price reference: ~$473–$473 on Oct 24, 2025. (stockanalysis.com)

Assumptions (documented)

  • Base FCFE (Year 1, FY2026 proxy): $5.0B; Bear $4.5B; Bull $6.0B. Cross‑checked to FY25 NI and operating cash‑flow context. (investing.com)
  • 5‑year FCFE growth: Base 2.0% (mix + lifecycle; cycle normalizes), Bear 0%, Bull 3.5%.
  • Terminal growth: 2.0% Base (range 1.5–2.25%) for a mature, high‑share OEM.
  • Discount rate (cost of equity): 9.0% Base (range 8.5–9.5%) given the 10‑yr near 4%. (ycharts.com)

DCF math (rounded, billions; details shown so you can replicate)

  • Base: FCFE0=$5.0 → grow 2% for 5 yrs.
    • PV(Years 1–5) ≈ $19.3B.
    • Terminal: FCFE5 ≈ $5.0×1.02^5 ≈ $5.52B; TV = $5.52×1.02/(0.09–0.02) ≈ $80.4B; PV(TV) ≈ $52.2B.
    • Equity value ≈ $71.5B → ≈ $265/share on 270.3M shares.
  • Bear (FCFE $4.5B; 0% growth; r=9.5%; g=1.5%): equity ≈ $61–$65B → ~$225–$240/share.
  • Bull (FCFE $6.0B; 3.5% growth; r=8.5%; g=2.25%): equity ≈ $95–$102B → ~$350–$375/share.

DCF takeaway

  • Our intrinsic range clusters around ~$225–$375 with a base around ~$265/share. Shares around ~$473 imply the market is discounting higher sustainable FCFE and/or a lower cost of equity and faster recovery than our base.

Reality check: Comparables

  • DE trades ~25x forward P/E (trailing ~25x). CAT trades ~28x forward; AGCO ~17–20x forward depending on source. On simple P/E, Deere sits between a premium global peer (CAT) and a value‑tilted peer (AGCO). (stockanalysis.com)

What could move the needle vs. our base

  • Upside
    • Faster mix shift to high‑margin lifecycle revenue (parts, services, upgrades) and precision features adoption; autonomy commercialization; a gentler rate path (lower discount rate lifts DCF). (s22.q4cdn.com)
  • Downside
    • Tariff headwinds (~$500M est. 2025), weaker farm income, dealer inventory overhang taking longer to clear; construction pricing pressure. (wsj.com)

Investment view and valuation range

  • DCF range (consolidated FCFE): ~$225 (bear) to ~$375 (bull), base ≈ $265/share.
  • Market context: ~ $473/share on Oct 24, 2025. On our conservative framework, Deere is an excellent franchise but not a classic “value” at today’s price.

Bottom line

  • Recommendation: Watchlist/Hold. For strict value, we’d prefer an entry closer to the upper‑$200s to mid‑$300s (where our base/bull overlap), or we’d need fresh evidence that sustainable FCFE is $6–7B with durable mid‑single‑digit growth, or that rates structurally reset lower. Triggers to upgrade: (1) clear acceleration in high‑margin lifecycle revenue, (2) stabilization of North American Large Ag demand, and (3) easing tariff burden. (s22.q4cdn.com)

How we built the valuation (step‑by‑step, fully sourced)

  1. Establish a sustainable cash‑flow base
  • Management narrowed FY25 net income to $4.75–$5.25B and presented cash‑flow context; we proxy sustainable FCFE at ~$5.0B, acknowledging Deere’s finance arm can swing reported cash. (investing.com)
  1. Cross‑check with the cycle and segments
  • FY25 segment outlook: PPA −15–20%, SAT ~−10%, C&F −10–15% (Q3 slides/coverage); this supports low growth in the near term before a mid‑cycle recovery. (investing.com)
  1. Set discount rate and terminal growth
  • With the 10‑yr at ~4.0% in late Oct 2025, a 9.0% COE is reasonable for a cyclical OEM; we sensitized 8.5–9.5%. Terminal growth 1.5–2.25% reflects mature‑market constraints. (ycharts.com)
  1. Forecast years 1–5
  • Base FCFE growth at 2% (productivity + lifecycle offsetting muted volumes), bear at 0%, bull at 3.5%. This is consistent with management’s cautious 2025 and a normalized mid‑cycle starting FY26. (investing.com)
  1. Terminal value and per‑share math
  • Gordon growth on Year‑5 FCFE; discounted at the chosen COE. Shares ~270.3M. (stockanalysis.com)
  1. Comps triangulation
  • Compared DE’s forward P/E vs. CAT and AGCO; DE sits between a premium peer and a value peer, backing up the “great company, price is the debate” conclusion. (stockanalysis.com)
  1. New risks since mid‑year
  • Tariffs (company indicated ~half‑billion 2025 headwind); soft farm income; demand normalization in construction—each argues for conservatism in the base case. (wsj.com)

“Why the chatter can be off”

  • “It’s just another cyclical equipment maker.” Deere’s precision/agtech stack and the Operations Center aim to raise recurring, lifecycle revenue and customer switching costs—this is not the 2010s playbook. That said, we still treat the terminal as mature, not SaaS‑like. (s22.q4cdn.com)
  • “Rates don’t matter for DE.” At ~4% 10‑yr, a 50–100 bps swing materially changes DCF. If rates trend below 4% for long, our $/share would lift. (ycharts.com)
  • “Tariffs are noise.” Management and outside coverage pointed to hundreds of millions of 2025 headwinds—material for any value case. (wsj.com)

One‑page snapshot

  • What they do: Global leader in ag and construction equipment plus financing; pushing autonomy/precision to improve customer ROI and lift lifecycle economics. (s22.q4cdn.com)
  • 2025 setup: Net income outlook $4.75–$5.25B; segment sales down double digits, especially Large Ag; inventory/production remains tightly managed. (investing.com)
  • Valuation: FCFE DCF ~$225–$375/share (base ~$265) vs. market ~$473; not a classic value today absent stronger FCFE trajectory or lower discount rates.
  • Watch items: cadence of precision upgrades adoption, mix of high‑margin lifecycle revenue, tariff policy/costs, dealer inventory health, and the 10‑yr trend. (s22.q4cdn.com)

Appendices

  • Rate context (10‑yr U.S. Treasury): ~4.02% on Oct 24, 2025, with recent dips below 4% intraday; our COE uses a ~4% risk‑free. (ycharts.com)
  • Trading snapshot (Oct 24, 2025): DE ~$472.76; shares ~270.33M; market cap ~$128B. Used for per‑share math only. (stockanalysis.com)

Sources (selected)

  • Deere FY25 Q1–Q3 releases and 10‑Q; Jan 2025 Investor Presentation (strategy, connected fleet, cash flow); third‑party coverage for Q3 outlook slides. (deere.com)
  • Reuters, Barron’s, WSJ, CNBC, Investopedia for guidance changes, tariff impacts, and market reaction. (reuters.com)
  • YCharts/ETFdb/Seeking Alpha for 10‑yr yield snapshots. (ycharts.com)
  • Peer comps: StockAnalysis, GuruFocus, Zacks. (stockanalysis.com)

If you want, I can share my spreadsheet with the DCF sensitivities (FCFE base, discount rate, and terminal growth), plus a simple “what needs to be true” bridge from ~$265 to the current price.