Designing for Excellence: Beyond Average Users

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: Paul Graham — “Good design is timeless, and if you want something timeless you can't pander to the limitations of some hypothetical 'average' user. It's too vague a target.”[1]

Programmer, investor, and essayist Paul Graham argues good design targets performance for demanding users first—like a Porsche 911 over a Cadillac—creating tools that elevate experts, which then benefit everyone as standards rise.[1]

Chew on this

  • Power users lead: Design for top performers (e.g., Lisp for elite coders); average-user focus yields forgettable results.[1]
  • Timeless counterintuition: Avoid "average" traps; great designs feel elite, like fast cars or precise proofs, enduring fashions.[1]
  • Objective taste: Simplicity, daring, redesign—universal across math, art, code; learn by spotting ugly vs. strangely beautiful.[2]

Try this today (Graham Power Audit)

  1. ID demanding users: List 3 power users for your design; note their pain points.[1]
  2. Boost performance: Prototype one elite feature; test if it feels "timeless."[1]
  3. Cascade check: Simplify for broader use; compare pre/post "average" appeal.[2]

Sources