Unlocking Creativity: The McDonald's Effect

Edition 54: The McDonald’s Theory of Creativity

The Idea

“An interesting thing happens. Everyone unanimously agrees that we can’t possibly go to McDonald’s, and better lunch suggestions emerge. Magic! It’s as if we’ve broken the ice with the worst possible idea, and now that the discussion has started, people suddenly get very creative. I call it the McDonald’s Theory: people are inspired to come up with good ideas to ward off bad ones.”
— Jon Bell

The idea
When a creative team or individual feels stuck, deliberately propose the most obvious, clichéd, or even terrible idea first. The shared rejection of it lowers the stakes, sparks conversation, and clears mental space for stronger alternatives to surface. The “bad” suggestion acts as a catalyst rather than a destination—turning hesitation into momentum.

Who said it (and the context)
Jon Bell is a writer and designer focused on creativity, decision-making, and everyday problem-solving. His reflections appear in essays and talks that explore practical psychology behind idea generation. Barnsworth Burning surfaces this observation within its broader collection on creativity, pairing it with other prompts for breaking creative inertia. The idea sits comfortably alongside discussions of constraints, play, and iterative making found throughout the site.[1]

A small expansion
In practice, the McDonald’s Theory works because it externalizes the fear of mediocrity. In a branding workshop, start by saying, “Let’s just use a generic sans-serif logo and stock photography.” The immediate pushback (“No way—that’s too safe”) often leads to sharper, more distinctive directions. A product designer might sketch the most literal, boring interface first; the group’s reactions then highlight what actually needs invention. The technique scales to solo work too: write the most obvious headline or composition you can imagine, then react against it. The result feels less like forced originality and more like a natural emergence from dialogue—whether with others or with your own critical eye.

Another lens on the idea
This pairs interestingly with Brian Eno’s concept of “scenius” (the intelligence of a scene or small creative community). Where the McDonald’s Theory uses a deliberately poor starting point to unlock better thinking, scenius emphasizes the surrounding culture and collaborators that make bold ideas possible in the first place. Both reject the lone-genius myth: one by engineering a safe “bad” prompt to start the flow, the other by recognizing that creativity thrives in supportive, idea-rich environments. Together they suggest that the spark often comes from social or self-imposed friction rather than solitary brilliance.[1]

Why this matters across art and design

  • Visual identity: Brainstorm sessions that begin with safe or clichéd directions quickly surface distinctive visual languages instead of default corporate looks.
  • Product & UX: Early “worst-case” wireframes or flows make real usability and delight needs obvious through contrast.
  • Architecture: Proposing the most generic floor plan first can reveal opportunities for light, circulation, or social gathering that a polished starting sketch might obscure.
  • Studio art: Beginning a piece with the most literal or expected mark invites surprising deviations that carry personal voice.

Two quick drills

  1. Worst-First Sketch (15–20 minutes)
    In your current project, spend five minutes making the most obvious, boring, or “wrong” version possible. Then spend the remaining time reacting against it—what feels off, and what better path does that reveal?

  2. Lunch-Table Prompt (ongoing)
    When stuck in a meeting or solo session, explicitly name the “McDonald’s option.” Notice how quickly the room (or your own thinking) generates alternatives once the low bar is set.

Thread to remember
This edition adds a light, tactical tool to the ongoing theme of attentive making—showing how even a playful, low-stakes prompt can open space for responsive, iterative creativity. It builds on earlier explorations of constraints, emergence, and small-team dynamics while offering a simple ritual for when momentum stalls.

Sources

  • Central idea drawn from Barnsworth Burning’s Creativity collection, featuring Jon Bell’s McDonald’s Theory.[1]
  • Complementary perspective informed by discussions of scenius and collaborative creativity on the site.

Try this today: In your next sketch, meeting, or brainstorm, name the “McDonald’s option” first and watch what emerges in its wake.