Creativity Through Contrast: The McDonald’s Theory
The Daily Interesting — Art & Design Edition
June 12, 2026
The McDonald’s Theory: Creativity Through Contrast
The idea
I call it the McDonald’s Theory: people are inspired to come up with good ideas to ward off bad ones.
— From Barnsworth Burning extracts on Jon Bell’s article.[1]
Who said it (and the context)
Jon Bell, a writer and designer known for exploring everyday creativity and decision-making, proposed this idea in a Medium article as a simple, practical observation about how the mind works under pressure. It emerged from reflecting on real-world choices—like picking a restaurant—where the presence of an obviously mediocre option (the fast-food default) sharpens focus on better alternatives.
A small expansion
Bell’s theory flips the usual creative advice on its head. Instead of starting with a blank slate or chasing perfection, you deliberately surface or imagine a weak, obvious, or “bad” idea first. This contrast acts like a creative repellent: the mind recoils and generates stronger alternatives to escape the mediocrity. In practice, it turns hesitation or fear of bad output into fuel—by naming the McDonald’s-level idea explicitly, you clear space for something more thoughtful, surprising, or elegant to emerge.
Another lens on the idea
This echoes Brian Eno’s well-known approach to creative constraints, where limitations (including self-imposed “bad” starting points) force invention. Eno often begins sessions with deliberately awkward or low-fidelity prompts to break habitual thinking. Where Bell emphasizes psychological contrast to avoid the obvious, Eno leans into playful acceptance of the awkward as generative. Both show that creativity thrives not in pure freedom, but in productive friction with the subpar.
Why this matters across art and design
Visual identity
Brand concepts gain edge when teams first sketch the most clichéd logo or color palette, then react against it to reach fresher territory.Product & UX
Interface ideas improve when designers prototype the most generic or frustrating flow first, making the flaws obvious and the improvements immediate.Architecture
Spatial proposals sharpen when an initial “safe but boring” massing or material choice is named, prompting bolder responses that better serve users.Studio art
Sketching sessions benefit from quickly drawing the most predictable composition, then letting the reaction generate unexpected marks, textures, or narratives.
Two quick drills
McDonald’s Sketch (10 minutes)
For any current project, spend two minutes drawing or describing the most obvious, clichéd, or “bad” solution you can think of. Then spend the remaining time reacting against it—what would make it the opposite?Default Audit (15 minutes)
List three default or “McDonald’s-level” choices in a recent piece of work (color, layout, interaction). For each, generate at least two alternatives that actively push away from the obvious.
Thread to remember
This idea of using contrast and deliberate mediocrity as a spark connects to earlier explorations of living order, responsive systems, and working with material resistance—showing once again that creativity often emerges from friction rather than flawless starting conditions.
Sources
- Central idea: Barnsworth Burning extracts on Jon Bell’s “The McDonald’s Theory of Creativity.”[1]
- Supporting context drawn from related discussions of creative constraints on the site.
Try this today: Name the most obvious or mediocre idea for your current project—then watch what happens when you push against it.