Redefining Design: Plans as Dynamic Resources

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: Lucy Suchman — Plans As Resources, Not Scripts

“Plans are not the determinants of action, in sum, but rather are resources to be constructed and consulted by actors before and after the fact.” — Lucy Suchman, Human Studies (1988). (resolve.cambridge.org)

Suchman’s deep take: good design respects reality’s messiness. People don’t execute prewritten scripts; they improvise in context. Treat plans, roadmaps, and specs as scaffolds that help users (and teams) orient, not as control structures that dictate every move. When design assumes situated action, it builds artifacts that are legible, forgiving, and adaptable in the wild. (cambridge.org)

How to design for situated action (quick pass)

  • Prefer orientation over orchestration: show direction and guardrails, not step‑by‑step lockstep. Tooltips, examples, and “good defaults” beat rigid wizards. (cambridge.org)
  • Make recovery cheaper than perfection: visible undo, draft modes, and graceful error states acknowledge that users will adapt on the fly. (en.wikipedia.org)
  • Validate in context, not just in lab: observe real workflows where improvisation happens; update the design and the plan together. (womenofixd.com)

Carry this line today: design plans people can lean on—then get out of their way.