Design: Shaping Us Through Our Tools
What Is Good Design?
Today’s Lens: John Culkin — Tools turn into environments, and environments turn into us
“We become what we behold. We shape our tools and then our tools shape us.” — John M. Culkin, S.J., 1967. (unz.com)
Culkin’s provocation (often misattributed to McLuhan) is a designer’s litmus test: the thing you ship isn’t just a product; it’s a small environment that trains attention, habits, and values. Good design, then, isn’t only about ease or delight—it’s about the kind of person your environment is cultivating. If “the medium is the message,” design’s moral center is to ensure the medium’s ongoing effects match your stated intent. (hannemyr.com)
Try this today (a 10‑minute “shaping audit”):
- Name the environment your product creates in one sentence (e.g., “constant alerts,” “quiet focus,” “coaching toward expertise”). Does that align with your mission? (hannemyr.com)
- Inspect three defaults (notifications, sorting, and repetitions). Which behaviors do they amplify over a week of use? Keep only the ones that grow the user you want to see more of.
- Rewrite one metric to reflect becoming, not just doing (e.g., “uninterrupted 25‑minute sessions per user” instead of “daily active minutes”). If the medium is shaping association and action, measure that shaping directly. (hannemyr.com)
—
Sources
- John M. Culkin, “A Schoolman’s Guide to Marshall McLuhan,” Saturday Review, March 18, 1967. Archive listing and scanned issue. (discoverarchives.library.utoronto.ca)
- Marshall McLuhan, Understanding Media: The Extensions of Man, ch. 1 (“The medium is the message”), p. 9 (excerpted). (hannemyr.com)
- Context on Culkin’s line and common misattribution. (mcluhangalaxy.wordpress.com)