Value Radar: Fresh Picks & Union Pacific Insights

Value Radar: 10 Fresh Candidates, then a Full Deep‑Dive on Union Pacific (UNP)

Date: November 1, 2025 (United States)

This research is for educational purposes only, not investment advice. Every key assumption is sourced so you can audit it.

Quick scan: 10 value candidates worth fresh attention

  • Union Pacific (UNP) — record‑efficient operations (sub‑60% operating ratio in Q2–Q3), rising service metrics, dividend raised to $1.38/qtr (Sept pay), and a proposed $85B combination with Norfolk Southern to form the first U.S. transcontinental railroad (regulatory review pending). We deep‑dive below. (investor.unionpacific.com)

  • CSX (CSX) — resilient network with improving velocity/dwell and modest volume growth; Q3 adjusted EPS $0.44; continued buybacks and dividends. (csx.com)

  • Canadian National (CNI) — 2025 plan for mid/high‑single‑digit EPS growth, OR improvement and ~C$3.4B capex; sequential margin progress in 1H/3Q. (cn.ca)

  • American Tower (AMT) — AFFO outlook raised; robust leasing/data‑center demand tied to 5G and AI; dividend grower. (wsj.com)

  • Waste Connections (WCN) — steady pricing, margin expansion, double‑digit dividend hike; FCF supports M&A plus buybacks. (investors.wasteconnections.com)

  • Kimberly‑Clark (KMB) — margin rebuild under “Transformation Initiative” and portfolio reshaping (Suzano JV for international tissue). Watch 2026 mix/returns. (prnewswire.com)

  • Colgate‑Palmolive (CL) — category lead with 41% toothpaste share; low‑single‑digit organic growth/gross margin stability despite tariff noise. (investor.colgatepalmolive.com)

  • Mondelez (MDLZ) — FCF >$3B guide with 4%+ organic growth amid EPS reset; chocolate/biscuit scale remains attractive. (globenewswire.com)

  • PepsiCo (PEP) — dividend growth and global scale; near‑term top‑line softness in North America is the opportunity to price for value, not growth. (investopedia.com)

  • Omnicom + Interpublic (OMC/IPG) — merger expected to close in 2H25; scale/AI platform synergies could re‑rate combined entity. (Regulatory approvals advancing.) (reuters.com)

Pick of the edition: Union Pacific (UNP)

A classic cash engine with improving service/productivity and a potential step‑change if the Norfolk Southern (NSC) merger is approved. We build a ground‑up valuation, stress the key assumptions, and compare to peers.

What’s changed recently — why now

  • Better execution, better cash engine: UNP posted sub‑60% operating ratios in Q2 (59.0% reported; 58.1% adjusted) and Q3 (59.2% reported; 58.5% adjusted), alongside record service metrics (e.g., higher freight car velocity, lower dwell, longer trains), and higher EPS vs. 2024. (investor.unionpacific.com)

  • Capital returns still robust: the Board lifted the quarterly dividend by 3% to $1.38 (paid Sept 30, 2025). Share repurchases are targeted at $4.0–$4.5B in 2025, consistent with Investor Day. (up.com)

  • Strategic catalyst: UNP agreed to acquire NSC in a stock‑and‑cash deal valuing NSC at ~$85B; management frames ~$2.75B annual synergies and coast‑to‑coast single‑line service benefits. Approval is not assured; STB review is the gating factor. (investopedia.com)

Business snapshot and roadmap (plain‑English)

  • What UNP does: moves bulk (grain, coal, fertilizer), industrial (chemicals, metals), and premium (intermodal/automotive) freight across 23 western U.S. states. Efficiency and on‑time service drive margins and cash. (investor.unionpacific.com)

  • 2025 cadence: volumes mixed (coal/weather/trade), but pricing above inflation and efficiency underpin EPS CAGR targets (high‑single to low‑double digits). Capex plan about $3.4B supports safety, reliability, and capacity. (investor.unionpacific.com)

  • Why margins improved: fewer delays (higher car velocity, lower dwell), longer trains, and better locomotive productivity. That’s showing up as a ~58–59% operating ratio vs. 60%+ a year ago. (investor.unionpacific.com)

Ground‑up valuation: FCFE DCF and comps

How we define cash:

  • For valuation, we use Free Cash Flow to Equity (FCFE) in the standard sense: operating cash flow (OCF) minus capital expenditures, adjusted for routine financing if needed. We do NOT subtract dividends in the base FCFE used for intrinsic value, because dividends are a discretionary use of equity cash, not a driver of it. (UNP also reports a “free cash flow” after dividends; we cite both for transparency.) (investor.unionpacific.com)

Key anchors you can audit

  • 2024 OCF and capex (proxy for FCFE before dividends): OCF $9.35B, investing cash outflow $3.33B → ≈$6.0B FCFE pre‑dividends in 2024. UNP’s own “free cash flow” after dividends was $2.81B. We model from the pre‑dividend figure. (investor.unionpacific.com)

  • 2025 run‑rate context: capital plan ~$3.4B; company continues to target large buybacks, implying healthy OCF. Q2 YTD 2025 “free cash flow” (company’s post‑dividend metric) was $1.105B; with a stronger back half and higher service metrics, we set a conservative 2025 FCFE (pre‑dividends) base at ~$6.0B again. (investor.unionpacific.com)

  • Shares outstanding: ~593M. Market cap recently about $128B; stock around $215–$218 in late October. Dividend yield ~2.5%. We use 593M for per‑share math. (stockanalysis.com)

  • Discount rate and long‑run growth: 10‑yr U.S. Treasury ~4.0–4.1% late October; we set a 9.0% base cost of equity (Rf ~4.1% + ~4.9% ERP). Terminal growth 2.0%. We sensitivity‑test 8–10% and 1.5–2.5% respectively. (ycharts.com)

  • 5‑year FCFE growth: 3.5% base case, reflecting pricing above inflation, efficiency (OR <60%), and modest volume, offset by coal headwinds and tariff/trade noise. Cross‑reference to UNP’s high‑single/low‑double‑digit EPS CAGR ambition and CN’s mid/high‑single EPS guide for 2025 as reality checks. (reuters.com)

DCF mechanics (our build)

  • Base FCFE (2025E): $6.0B
  • Years 1–5 FCFE growth: 3.5% → $6.21, $6.43, $6.66, $6.89, $7.13 (billions)
  • Cost of equity (r): 9.0%
  • Terminal growth (g): 2.0%
  • PV of 5‑yr FCFE ≈ $25.8B; PV of terminal value ≈ $67.5B → Equity value ≈ $93.3B.
  • Per share (593M): ≈ $157.

Sensitivity highlights (per share)

  • r = 8%, g(5‑yr) = 4.5% → ~$194
  • r = 8.5%, g(5‑yr) = 4.0% → ~$181
  • r = 9.5%, g(5‑yr) = 3.0% → ~$143
  • Add merger synergies (illustrative): if sustainable FCFE rises to ~$7.0B by year 5 (post‑integration) with same r=9%/g=2%, base value lifts to roughly ~$175–$185. This assumes some portion of the touted ~$2.75B EBITDA synergies translates to durable equity cash after integration costs and capex. Regulatory/exec risk is material. (barrons.com)

What this means today

  • With shares around $215–$218 at 10/31 close‑week, our base DCF (~$157) says UNP is a high‑quality franchise trading above conservative intrinsic value using today’s stand‑alone cash engine and a 9% cost of equity. The market appears to be discounting either (a) a lower effective cost of equity, (b) higher sustainable FCFE growth, and/or (c) some probability‑weighted NSC synergy. (google.com)

Comparable checks (today’s context)

  • FCF yield (pre‑dividends): ~$6.0B on ~$128B market cap ≈ ~4.7%. Dividend yield ~2.5%. Peers screen in a similar mid‑single‑digit FCF range on cleaner years. (stockanalysis.com)

  • Operating ratios (recent):

    • UNP: 59.0% (Q2, adj. 58.1%); 59.2% (Q3, adj. 58.5%). (investor.unionpacific.com)
    • CN: improving to low‑60s in 2025; guide eased to mid/high‑single EPS growth amid tariff/trade volatility. (cn.ca)
    • CSX: Q3 adj. operating margin 34.9% (implies OR ~65.1%); network KPIs improving. (csx.com)
  • P/E snapshot: UNP ~18–18.5x forward — a premium for quality and potential merger optionality rather than “deep value.” (stockanalysis.com)

Investment view and verdict

  • Thesis in a sentence: UNP is an elite railroad getting demonstrably more efficient, with shareholder‑friendly capital returns and a potentially transformative merger — but at today’s price the stock bakes in a fair share of that future.

  • Our valuation range (stand‑alone): $143–$194 per share (midpoint ≈ $168), anchored by r=8.5–9.5%, 5‑yr FCFE growth 3–4.5%, and 2% terminal growth.

  • Merger kicker (probability‑weighted): If you assign, for example, a 40% probability to the NSC deal closing with 50% of stated EBITDA synergies converting to lasting FCFE by year 5, you could justify adding roughly $10–$15/share to the stand‑alone midpoint (very rough, depends on financing mix and integration cadence). Regulatory approval is the key swing factor. (investopedia.com)

  • Bottom line (action): Quality at a fair‑to‑full price. On pure value, we’d wait for a better entry (roughly <$185 on our base math) or for clearer line‑of‑sight that sustainable FCFE is stepping up (toward ~$7B+ run‑rate) — whether from continued OR gains or credible merger synergy capture. For value‑minded buyers who want rail exposure now, legging in on weakness and reinvesting dividends makes sense if you underwrite at least mid‑single FCFE growth and keep merger expectations conservative. (up.com)

Why some “value” chatter may be off

  • “It’s cheap vs. history.” Not on cash: a ~4.7% pre‑dividend FCF yield with macro/rate risk near 4.0–4.1% on the 10‑year isn’t a layup. If the market’s cost of equity drifts higher, DCFs compress fast. (files.advisorperspectives.com)

  • “The merger is guaranteed.” It isn’t. The STB’s post‑2001 merger rules are stringent. Support exists, but large shippers and competitors are already voicing concerns; timeline uncertainty is real. We don’t capitalize 100% of synergies. (apnews.com)

Step‑by‑step: how we built the model (documented)

  1. Established FCFE baseline from primary statements: 2024 OCF $9.35B and investing cash outflow $3.33B → ~$6.0B FCFE pre‑dividends; UNP’s post‑dividend “free cash flow” was $2.81B (we cite both; we model off the pre‑dividend figure). (investor.unionpacific.com)

  2. Cross‑checked 2025 run‑rate: capex plan ~$3.4B; management signaling large buybacks; Q1/Q2 results affirmed EPS growth path and OR discipline; Q3 reiterated gains and highlighted top‑tier service metrics. We assume ~$6.0B FCFE base for 2025. (investor.unionpacific.com)

  3. Set discount rate: 10‑year at ~4.0–4.1% late October; base cost of equity 9.0% with sensitivity 8–10%. (ycharts.com)

  4. Modeled 5‑year FCFE CAGR 3.5%, 2% terminal growth: computed PV of explicit period and terminal → ~$93B equity; divided by ~593M shares → ~$157/share base value. Sensitized growth and r to form our value band. (stockanalysis.com)

  5. Cross‑checked against market and peers: current price ~$215–$218, dividend ~2.5%, FCF yield ~4.7%; peers’ OR and EPS guides add context. Conclusion: great business, not a classic “value” at today’s price unless you ascribe material probability to merger synergies. (google.com)

Key risks to monitor

  • Regulatory: STB review of the NSC deal; conditions, divestitures, or an outright block would change the long‑term cash path. (investopedia.com)

  • Macro/rates: if the 10‑year stays ~4.1% or rises, cost of equity pressure persists; slowing industrial activity or tariff shocks can hit volumes/mix. (files.advisorperspectives.com)

  • Mix and coal: coal remains cyclical and policy‑sensitive; grain/fertilizer can offset, but intermodal comparisons are choppy. (reuters.com)

  • Execution: keeping OR below 60% sustainably while investing ~$3.4B/year and maintaining service levels. (reuters.com)

If you want one value name to buy today…

Among North American rails, Canadian National (CNI) currently offers a cleaner stand‑alone setup (no mega‑merger risk), with improving OR and a mid‑to‑high‑single EPS growth plan into 2025–26. It’s not “cheap,” but on risk‑adjusted value, it’s arguably simpler than underwriting UNP’s merger. For ink‑still‑wet cash yields plus secular infrastructure exposure, American Tower (AMT) is also compelling on rising AFFO and dividend growth, though it is a REIT (rate‑sensitive). (cn.ca)


One‑page summary (UNP)

  • Thesis: elite franchise improving efficiency; dividend/buybacks intact; potential transformational NSC merger.
  • Valuation: stand‑alone DCF ≈ $157/share (r=9%, 3.5% FCFE CAGR 5yrs, 2% terminal). Sensitivity: ~$143 (bear) to ~$194 (bull).
  • Action: Hold/Watchlist; accumulate on pullbacks toward <$185 or on credible evidence of sustainable FCFE >$7B (post‑integration and/or further OR gains). (investor.unionpacific.com)

If you’d like, I can share a compact spreadsheet so you can flex discount rates, growth, and FCFE to see how the per‑share value moves.