Unpacking Clarity: The Art of Honest Communication
Title: The Hardest Truth in Making: Verlyn Klinkenborg on Knowing What You Actually Say
Know what each sentence says,
What it doesn't say,
And what it implies.
Of these, the hardest is knowing what each sentence actually says.[1]
The idea
Verlyn Klinkenborg urges makers to confront their own work with ruthless clarity. Before worrying about elegance, rhythm, or impact, first determine exactly what a single sentence (or mark, choice, or element) is doing—no more, no less. This discipline cuts through self-deception and reveals whether the thing you made is honest to its own intention. In design and art, it means asking of every line, color, or interface decision: What does this actually communicate, omit, or suggest?
Who said it (and the context)
Verlyn Klinkenborg is a writer, teacher, and former New York Times editorial board member whose slim book Several Short Sentences About Writing distills decades of craft into precise observations. His focus is not on rules or inspiration but on the minute, daily act of attention required to make language (or any medium) say what it truly means. The site excerpt captures his core challenge: the gap between what we think we’ve made and what is actually present.[1]
A small expansion
In visual work this same scrutiny applies. A logo mark, a product screen, or a spatial detail may look balanced or modern, yet upon close inspection it may quietly contradict its purpose, imply unintended hierarchy, or leave essential meaning unsaid. The practice is not pedantic editing but a form of attentive making: returning to the element until its actual effect matches its intended one. This echoes the newsletter’s ongoing thread of responsive dialogue between maker and material—here the “material” includes the designer’s own assumptions.
Another lens on the idea
Robert Bringhurst, in The Elements of Typographic Style, offers a complementary (and sometimes stricter) view. Where Klinkenborg stresses diagnostic honesty about what is present, Bringhurst insists that typography’s highest virtue is invisibility: letters must serve meaning without drawing attention to themselves. Both demand that the maker step outside ego and fashion to let the work reveal its true character. Klinkenborg supplies the diagnostic tool; Bringhurst supplies the ideal of transparent service to content.
Why this matters across art and design
- Visual identity: Every mark, weight, or negative space must be audited for what it actually communicates versus what the brief assumes.
- Product & UX: Interface elements often imply behaviors or hierarchies they do not deliver; Klinkenborg-style scrutiny prevents misleading affordances.
- Architecture: A detail may “say” solidity or lightness that the surrounding structure contradicts.
- Studio art: The work’s emotional or conceptual payload is only as strong as the artist’s willingness to name exactly what each choice contributes.
Two quick drills
Sentence (or Element) Audit (10 minutes)
Pick one finished piece. Isolate a single sentence, mark, or decision. Write down, in plain language: what it says, what it leaves out, and what it implies. Note any mismatch with your original intention.Implication Sketch (15 minutes)
Redraw or re-render the same element three ways: once emphasizing what it currently says, once stripping what it doesn’t need to say, and once clarifying what it should imply. Compare the versions.
Thread to remember
This edition sharpens the newsletter’s core theme of attentive making by turning the lens inward: great work begins with the courage to see what is actually there rather than what we hope or assume is there. It connects to prior explorations of peripheral vision, workmanship of risk, and the unfolding process—each a call to stay in honest dialogue with the emerging artifact.
Sources
- Central idea drawn from Verlyn Klinkenborg’s Several Short Sentences About Writing via Barnsworth Burning.
- Complementary perspective informed by Robert Bringhurst’s The Elements of Typographic Style (recurring reference on the site).
- Supporting context from the site’s extract and related writings on craft precision.
Try this today: In your next sketch, layout, or prototype, pause after the first pass. Ask aloud of one element: “What does this actually say?” Adjust until the answer is clear.