Reviving Playfulness in Web Design

Title: Breaking Free from the Web's Visual Sameness

“We used to make websites because it was fun but at some point, we lost the way. We need to make dumb shit! Make useless stuff; make the web fun again!”
— Boris Müller

The idea

Mainstream web design has settled into a sea of sameness—hero images, sans-serif fonts, predictable calls-to-action, and reusable UI kits. What began as a playful, experimental medium has hardened into convention and cliché. Distinctiveness fades as sites, logos, and interfaces converge on the same polished, risk-averse templates. The result is visual weariness: a web that feels efficient but rarely surprising or joyful.

Who said it (and the context)

Boris Müller, a designer and writer focused on user interfaces and digital culture, explores this in his essay “Why Do All Websites Look the Same?” The piece sits within ongoing conversations on Barnsworth Burning about web aesthetics, interfaces, and the loss of personality in digital spaces. Müller draws attention to how tools, templates, and market pressures have narrowed the visual language of the web, turning once-vibrant pages into interchangeable landing experiences.

A small expansion

Müller points to research showing websites have grown markedly more similar since 2010 in color, layout, and style. The same consolidation appears in typefaces (often slight variations on a few familiar sans-serifs), illustrations, and overall visual culture. His remedy is playful rebellion: create “dumb” or “useless” experiments that prioritize delight and personality over conversion metrics. These small acts of resistance keep the web alive as a medium for surprise rather than mere utility.

Another lens on the idea

A complementary perspective comes from Austin Kleon’s emphasis on remixing and personal voice. While Müller diagnoses the flattening effect of shared tools and templates, Kleon encourages active gathering of influences and bold recombination—exactly the kind of cross-pollination that could counteract aesthetic consolidation. Where Müller calls for breaking free through playful uselessness, Kleon frames originality as an act of generous theft and visible process. Both views champion distinctiveness, but Müller focuses on the web’s current fatigue while Kleon offers a practical mindset for injecting individuality.

Why this matters across art and design

  • Visual identity — Unique digital presences stand out when they reject generic templates in favor of hand-crafted quirks.
  • Product & UX — Interfaces that embrace surprise and personality create more memorable, human experiences than frictionless sameness.
  • Architecture — Digital “spaces” benefit from the same resistance to bland uniformity that physical buildings gain from thoughtful idiosyncrasy.
  • Studio art — Online portfolios and experiments thrive when makers treat the web as a canvas for play rather than polished delivery.

Two quick drills

  1. Anti-Template Sketch (15–20 minutes)
    Open a blank page and design a simple site section without any UI kit, stock photo, or familiar grid. Use only elements you invent or draw by hand. Notice what feels risky or fun.

  2. Sameness Audit (ongoing)
    Browse five sites in your field. List three shared visual habits. Then redesign one small element on your own project to deliberately break one of those habits.

Thread to remember

This extends the newsletter’s ongoing exploration of attentive making by urging creators to notice—and push against—the invisible pressures toward conformity. In a medium increasingly shaped by templates, deliberate oddity becomes another form of material dialogue and personal inscription.

Sources

  • Central idea drawn from Boris Müller’s “Why Do All Websites Look the Same?” on Barnsworth Burning.[1]
  • Complementary perspective informed by Austin Kleon’s ideas on remixing (featured across multiple entries on the site).

Try this today: Open a new browser tab and build the simplest possible webpage—just text and one image—using no templates or libraries. Make it weird on purpose. What happens when the web stops trying to look like everyone else?