Good Design: More Than Just A Picture
What Is Good Design?
Today’s Lens: Susan Kare — Road Signs, Not Illustrations
“Screen icons have a job to do — they’re more like traffic signs than illustrations.” — Susan Kare. (wired.com)
Kare’s point is deceptively deep: good design isn’t a picture of a thing; it’s a promise of what happens next. Like a road sign, a great interface element is pre-attentive (understood at a glance), durable (learned once, remembered always), and stripped of storybook detail so the action is unmistakable. As she notes elsewhere, simplicity isn’t a constraint—it’s the very reason the symbol includes only what guides behavior. (newyorker.com)
Put it to work
- The phone test: describe your icon in seven words; if two teammates draw it the same, you’re close.
- Reduce to silhouette: it must read at 16px in monochrome before you add style.
- One metaphor, no garnish: keep only features essential to the action; delete everything decorative.
- Family resemblance, sharp distinctions: unify stroke and angle, but exaggerate differences between actions to prevent slips.
- Measure memory: first-time explanation should stick—track repeat tooltips and misclicks as redesign signals.
References:
- Wired interview (2007) where Kare contrasts icons with illustrations. wired.com/2007/11/ps-macicons. (wired.com)
- The New Yorker profile (2018) on why extraneous detail harms clarity. newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/the-woman-who-gave-the-macintosh-a-smile. (newyorker.com)