Redefining Design: From Puzzles to Arguments

What Is Good Design?

Today’s Lens: Horst Rittel — Designing in the Presence of “Wicked Problems”

“Solutions to wicked problems are not true-or-false, but good-or-bad.” (en.wikipedia.org)

Rittel’s deep take reframes design from puzzle‑solving to argument‑making. When aims are contested and consequences ripple, “optimal” vanishes; all we have are better or worse moves, justified to specific stakeholders. Good design, then, is the craft of making our reasoning legible—surfacing trade‑offs, values, and bets—so a community can decide what “good” means here and now. That shifts the designer’s job from finding the answer to staging a transparent debate and owning the consequences of change. (colab.ws)

Put it to work (one‑minute drill)

  • Write the design as an argument: Issue → Options → Pros/Cons → Decision → Assumptions. Share the memo with stakeholders; update as evidence shifts. (Rittel’s IBIS method.) (en.wikipedia.org)
  • Evaluate outcomes with “better/worse” criteria users care about (safety, dignity, time saved), not binary success. Document who benefits and who pays. (nautilus.org)

Further reading: Rittel & Webber, “Dilemmas in a General Theory of Planning” (1973). (colab.ws)